Decision Maker: Council
Decision status: Recommendations Determined
Minute by the Lord Mayor
To Council:
In recent weeks there have been several
events focussed on continuing action to maintain, support and advance Sydney’s
and New South Wales’ culture, creativity and
nightlife. People participating in these gatherings have overwhelmingly
recognised the inter-relationship of arts, culture and nightlife and their
crucial contribution to tourism and the broader economy.
City of Sydney Councillors and staff attended
each of these events:
·
The launch of the NSW Productivity and Equality
Commission’s report, Review of regulatory barriers impeding a vibrant 24-hour
economy on 9 September 2025, which was subject of an earlier Lord Mayoral Minute.
·
The Art of Tax Reform Summit, held at Sydney Opera
House on 25 September 2025.
·
Arts, Culture and Sydney's Future, an event
co-hosted by Business Sydney and Sydney Festival on 20 October, 2025 which
explored the role of arts and culture in Sydney’s economic growth, global brand
and liveability.
·
The third annual NEON Forum, the Flagship event of
the Office NSW 24-Hour Economy Commissioner. Held over 2 days (26 and 27
October 2025), the Forum brought together local and international placemaking
and night-time economy experts, venue operators, arts organisations, local
government representatives and others with an interest in supporting and
building our nightlife. The first NSW Night Worker Action Plan 2025- 2028 was
also launched at the Forum.
These gatherings were not mere talkfests.
They each provided new ideas for action by all levels of Government working in
partnership with the cultural and creative community and our vibrant nightlife
sector.
Art of Tax Reform Summit
This Summit was informed by over 300
submissions from artists and creative workers, arts and cultural organisations,
peak bodies and tax professionals resulting in over 80 ideas. These included
proposals to increase philanthropic support for not-for-profit cultural
organisations, investment in live theatre, music venues and other cultural
activities, expansion of available affordable creative space, improving
artists' incomes and sustaining and strengthening the cultural and creative
sectors, many of which were further explored during the Summit. This was only
the beginning of a process to improve the financing of culture and creativity
in Australia.
In his speech to the Summit, Federal Arts
Minister Tony Burke committed to considering tax reform in the next iteration
of the national cultural policy due in 2028. Consultation for this policy will
begin in early 2026. The Summit was also attended by Arts Ministers from NSW,
Victoria, South Australia and Western Australia. At the end of the Summit, they
issued a joint communique in which they committed to making co-ordinated
submissions to the National Cultural Policy highlighting the ideas emerging from
the Summit.
Potential to increase tax revenue
Achieving tax reform will not be easy. A
paper summarising the submissions identified challenges in designing and
implementing such reform. These included the potential adverse fiscal impact of
new or expanded tax concessions. Yet this impact could be positive.
A submission by Live Performance argued that
a 40% tax incentive, similar to those which exist for the film industry, could
return $1.26 in tax revenue for every dollar in tax foregone. Another
submission quoted modelling by Oxford Economics which found that tax incentives
for music venues and live music activities could add $486 million to the
national economy and support 4,151 new jobs, resulting in increased tax
revenues.
Yet the potential tax for arts and cultural
activities to generate revenues through a range of taxes are not normally
considered in the budget process. Nor are the revenues are derived from the
external economic impacts of arts, cultural and creative activities, such as
taxes paid by hospitality, visitor accommodation, transport/travel, merchandise
and other businesses.
It is time that Governments consider both
sides of the ledger– both revenue foregone and the potential to generate
additional revenue, along with budget savings resulting from the positive
impacts of cultural activity on health, wellbeing, education and community
life.
Retaining existing cultural infrastructure
Tax reform must not be a substitute for
public funding. Indeed, new approaches to cultural funding are needed in
addition to the current focus on grants to organisations, projects and
programs. In an increasingly competitive environment, several organisations
have lost their funding or received insufficient funding to support their
activities. Others have had their funding reduced. This is already threatening
the potential loss of medium to long term closure of vital cultural
infrastructure which these organisations manage. These potential losses
highlight the need for a new funding stream to sustain existing small to medium
cultural infrastructure, especially spaces that offer affordable access for
creatives.
New revenue measure needed
Public funding, augmented by tax measures to
increase philanthropy and investment may not be sufficient to meet the needs of
the arts and cultural sector. New revenue raising measures may be needed, with
these revenues specifically directed towards the arts and culture.
The City’s submission to the Summit pointed
out that many countries and cities impose a tourism tax to raise revenue for
investment in the visitor experience – including arts and culture. These
include New York, Athens, Barcelona and Edinburgh, Manchester and Liverpool in
the United Kingdom. The UK Cultural Policy Unit has published a detailed paper
proposing a national levy in the form of a small charge would be imposed on
visitor accommodation room rates, particularly higher end visitor
accommodation. The paper argues the resulting slight increase in price would
not adversely impact overall tourism, but would be provide additional
investment in tourist related cultural facilities and events. This would free
up cultural funding which could be redirected to increase support for creatives
and the small-to-medium sector. The potential increase in cultural tourism
would also lead to increased tax revenues.
Greater transparency of existing cultural
funding
Any discussion on cultural funding requires
an understanding of existing public funding. At present this information is
scattered through annual reports, Ministerial media releases, answers to
questions on notice and questions asked in budget estimates committees and is
often subject to a time lag. Other information, such as public funding of
cultural festivals by Destination NSW, is “commercial in confidence”.
This information should be brought together
and made easily accessible. The reasons for insisting that information is
“commercial in confidence” should be fully explained.
NEON Forum
The NEON Forum brought together policymakers,
industry leaders, venue operators, creatives and local and international
experts. Over its 2 days, the Forum covered issues including city planning to
support nightlife, ensuring safety at night and in workplaces, particularly for
women and gender diverse people, actions to unlock creative spaces and the NSW
Government’s vibrancy reforms. The 24-Hour Economy Commissioner, Mike Rodrigues
also had conversations with the Sydney Metro CEO, Peter Regan, the NSW Productivity
and Equality Commissioner, Peter Achterstraat and the
new Police Commissioner, Mal Lanyon.
Mr Regan explained that the 4 obstacles to
24-hour public transport were cost, logistics, including integrating transport
modes, maintenance and upgrades. He also acknowledged that New Year’s Eve
demonstrated it is possible. Peter Achterstraat
revealed that the Commission had examined the impacts of the Enmore Road
Special Entertainment Precinct (SEP), revealing that property values had
increased by $1300/sqm, with a third of this attributable to the introduction
of the SEP. Mal Lanyon said he supported the NSW Government’s vibrancy reforms
and was committed to their implementation. He subsequently met Jeff Garcia, a
former New York police officer who headed the New York Mayor’s Office of
Nightlife. In this role, Mr Garcia had introduced new policies and procedures
to improve relationships between the police and venue owners. Mr Garcia will be
providing details to NSW Police.
City staff attended many of these sessions
and will draw on the information they gained to build on our own work to
support Sydney’s nightlife.
NSW Night Worker Action Plan 2025-2028
The Forum also saw the launch of the NSW
Night Worker Action Plan 2025-2028, prepared by the 24-Hour Economy
Commissioner’s Office (the Office). This workforce comprises 1.27 million
people working between 6pm and 6am across NSW, almost 29% of the total workforce.
There are 72,895 night workers within the Sydney CBD alone.
The Action Plan identifies 5 priorities to be
addressed:
·
economic insecurity
·
physical and mental wellbeing
·
access to essential services, childcare, transport
and amenities
·
safety and security (physical and sexual violence)
·
recognition of and advocacy related to night work
The Plan contains 25 actions to address these
priorities, including developing resources to support night workers, making
public space safe at night and undertaking research to better understand the
needs of the night workforce. Many of these actions complement work the City is
already undertaking. The City already participates in the Office’s working
groups which contributed to the Plan.
For example, one action requires exploring
opportunities to establish "gig worker hubs". These are dedicated
spaces where workers such as food delivery riders and ride share drivers can
rest, charge devices, access basic amenities and connect with multicultural
worker networks. Gig workers are amongst the lowest paid and have the least
economic security. Many of them also work within the City of Sydney and
neighbouring local government areas.
The City is able to advise on areas with the
greatest need for a gig worker hub as well as facilitate engagement with food
delivery companies and riders.
The Plan's transport-related actions are less
ambitious. It proposes "exploring utilisation of existing infrastructure
and potential public-private partnerships to expand car park access" and
"Investigate tailored transport solutions that can fill service gaps where
fixed-route transport is limited". The Government should go much further
and implement the Productivity and Equality Commission's recommendations to
improve frequency of and access to public transport at night, as well as
trialling later public transport services especially on weekends and in
high-activity areas, as endorsed by Council on 22 September 2025.
Notwithstanding this, Council should welcome
the NSW Night Worker Action Plan and play a role in implementing it.
the Rt HOn
CLOVER MOORE AO
Lord Mayor of Sydney
Moved by the Chair (the Lord Mayor) –
It is resolved that:
(A)
Council
commend the NSW Government for hosting the Art of Tax Reform Summit on 25
September 2025, attended by The Commonwealth, NSW, Victorian, South Australian
and Western Australian Arts Ministers, the Lord Mayor, the City of Sydney Chief
Executive Officer, relevant government officials, tax experts, cultural
organisation representatives and arts practitioners, noting that this Summit is
the beginning of a process to improve the financing of culture and creativity
in Australia;
(B)
Council
commend the Office of the 24-Hour Economy Commissioner for hosting the third
annual NEON Forum;
(C)
Council
welcome the NSW Night Worker Action Plan 2025-2028, notwithstanding its less
than ambitious actions relating to late night transport;
(D)
the
Lord Mayor be requested to write to the Prime Minister, the NSW Premier and
relevant Commonwealth and NSW Ministers requesting they each take action on the
matters which fall within their portfolios as set out in the subject Minute;
and
(E)
the
Chief Executive Officer be requested to:
(i)
work
with all interested parties to ensure that the optimism and momentum for action
on cultural financing arising from the Art of Tax Reform Summit is maintained;
(ii)
contribute
to future consultation processes including advocating on the matters raised in
the subject Minute, such as the Commonwealth Government's forthcoming
consultation for the next iteration of its Cultural Policy and updating Council
via the CEO Update with draft submissions for Councillor feedback prior to
finalisation;
(iii)
investigate
the extent to which the City is able to assist in implementing the NSW Night
Worker Action Plan 2025-2028 actions, including continuing to work with the
Office of the 24-Hour Economy Commissioner, and engaging with the Migrant
Workers Hub, Study NSW and Transport for NSW to explore establishing a gig
worker hub within or close to the Sydney CBD; and
(iv)
keep
Council updated on action on all of these matters via the CEO Update.
Carried unanimously.
S051491
Report author: Erin Cashman
Publication date: 17/11/2025
Date of decision: 17/11/2025
Decided at meeting: 17/11/2025 - Council
Accompanying Documents: